Am I the only one who, when I have to use porta-potty in a remote area (it’s surprising how many times I have to do this), expects a murdered body to be jammed in there?
I suspect I am not. I think most people who write mystery novels think that way.
I’m not sure which came first – my thinking that way, or my liking mysteries. Both have been with me my since my earliest memories. It may be a chicken and egg thing – people who think that way just naturally gravitate to mysteries. Or people who like to read and write mysteries just naturally think that way.
Mystery writers are frequently asked where they get their ideas. I’ve seen writers, famous and not so famous, asked this at almost every question and answer session I’ve ever been at.
My feeling always is if you have to ask, you’ll never understand.
Some of the more seasoned writers have a nice, smooth obviously well-used response. Others seem flummoxed and stammer through what to the listener is probably an unsatisfactory answer.
It’s a hard question to answer, because in my experience it’s like asking someone how they breathe or walk or blink their eyes – it just is.
Here’s what I’ve learned about ideas:
• Ideas are everywhere. They come to me day and night. I jot them down, rip stories out of the newspaper, send myself emails. It can be something in the news or as simple as a remark someone makes. Today I read a quote in a newspaper story, an innocuous aside someone made, and it spurred an idea.
• Wish I could remember what that quote was, because now I have to go through the newspaper and find the quote again and hope I remember the idea because I didn’t write it down. Ideas are like fruit flies. If you don’t make note of them immediately, they will probably die. There may be some residue left where they once flitted around and landed, but it will definitely not be a living, flitting fly. Ideas are important and when a writer gets one, she needs to hold onto it. That’s why there are scraps of paper and legal pads all over my house with phrases and paragraphs on them that would probably give investigators fits if I were ever one of those bodies found stuffed in a porta-potty.
• You can start generating an idea with the beautiful question “what if?” That’s a great way to get the pump primed. But you have to let it grow, let it take hold in your brain and get bigger. Sit back and allow it to happen and then other ones will come without the prompt.
The ability to see ideas – the big ones that a book will be based on and all the little ones that go into making that book good and interesting – is often overlooked when the tools of writing are discussed. I’m not sure it can be learned or if it’s something a person just has.
My guess is that it’s like a lot of other of those intangibles that go into being a committed writer – some people have it in spades, others a little bit, some have to work at it. Those who don’t recognize it or understand it, who muse “Gosh, I wonder where writers get their ideas?” as they sit down to write, probably are not going to have a lot of luck with it.
I’m frequently appalled at the lack of curiosity, creative thinking and observational skills I see in people around me. Those are the seeds from where ideas grow. But like ideas themselves, I couldn’t tell you where they come from.
- The Macavity Awards were announced at opening ceremonies at Bouchercon in Toronto mysteryreadersinc.blogspot.ca/2017/10/macavi… 2 days ago
- Deadly Pleasures Mystery Magazine announced the winners of the 2017 Barry Awards last night mysteryreadersinc.blogspot.ca/2017/10/barry-… 2 days ago
- This week's Facebook question - how did you find out about Sisters In Crime? Check out their 2017 report sistersincrime.org/page/raisingwo… #SinC30 5 days ago
- RT @Clea_Simon: Proud to be a member @SINCnational @SinCNE ! @SincNational highlights that we've done over 30 years: https://t.co/cMFOT0Law… 5 days ago
- NPR review of THE OBAMA INHERITANCE with nice mention of @kateflora short story with Michelle Obama as a vigilante npr.org/2017/10/09/556… 6 days ago
- Happy launch to Leigh Perry and Sid the Skeleton for THE SKELETON PAINTS A PICTURE @ToniLPKelner @Family_Skeleton amazon.com/Skeleton-Paint… 6 days ago
- Stuck on a scene? Hank has a helpful list of reasons why you might be stuck and banishes writer's block. careerauthors.com/writers-block-… @HankPRyan 1 week ago
CategoriesAwards Barbara Ross Beth Kanell Blog Summary Book promotion Carlotta Carlyle Conferences Craft Crime Bake Dogs Edith Maxwell Editing Em Moore Event Recap G.M. Malliet Genre Guppies Hallie Ephron Hank Phillippi Ryan Interview J.P. Choquette Judy Copek Kate Flora Lea Wait Libraries Linda Barnes Lisa Haselton Marketing Maureen Milliken Member News Members Michele Dorsey Mo Walsh Nancy Gardner Not Quite Twenty Questions Of Interest Opinion Pat Remick Pauline Alldred Ray Anderson Readers Rosemary Harris SinCNE Social Media Speakers' Bureau Uncategorized Upcoming Events Writers Writing Writing challenges and contests Writing lessons Writing resources Young Adult