The biggest piece of advice for all of us who write is to not be afraid of revision. Well, more than that actually – to know revision is inevitable and necessary.
When I was a freelance book editor the number one issue I saw with most of the books I edited – almost every single one of them — is that they weren’t finished. People were sending me first drafts, thinking they had a finished product. Some would listen to me when I told them they had a lot more work to do, some wouldn’t. No skin off my nose – they’d find out soon enough what they had when they tried to pitch it.
I was pretty sure I’d done a good job of finishing my own first mystery novel. I’d written, rewritten, had people read it, wrote more, went through it again. I’d done so many revisions, I was sick of the book. Almost hated it. But I was sure it was done.
Last year at Crimebake, a fellow sister in crime asked me if I’d like to read her manuscript. Sure, I said. But she wanted to read mine in exchange. It was only fair. OK, I said, but don’t go suggesting any changes, because I’m done. Of course, I quickly realized how stupid that was and told her to make any suggestions she saw fit.
She did. And I realized I wasn’t done.
It had been a year after I’d “finished” writing the book, and the layoff combined with her suggestions helped. I made a lot of revisions with her help and deemed the book done.
And so it was, until I started thinking about my so far unsuccessful query process. Particularly, how much trouble I’d had answering an agent’s question about my hook at Crimebake last year. I realized I had to dig a little deeper and get that hook in. Which I did. Voila! This time I really was done.
Until I decided to enter it in a first mystery novel contest last spring that had a 90,000-word limit. My book was closer to 96,000. I figured I could kill 6,000 words and maybe make the book a little better. So I went through it again, discovering a plot flaw along the way. Done! Better, tighter book.
A couple months ago, an agent asked to see the full manuscript. I’d been down that road before, but was still pretty excited now that my book was really done.
Eight weeks later, her assistant sent the rejection, along with some feedback. I don’t mind getting feedback, but this feedback was so general, so very generic, at first I deemed it unhelpful. But then I started thinking about it. Maybe I could go through the book again and see if I could figure out what she was talking about. No harm there.
Around the same time, I was reading a book by an author I admire who has a unique voice. It made me start thinking about voice in my own book. While this was not one of the agent’s criticisms, I started getting this nagging little feeling that when I wrote the book I held back, didn’t use my full voice.
So I’m going to go through it one more time. Even though it’s done.
- RT @edithmaxwell: My @midnightinkbook #Quaker #Midwife #Mystery stars in Poetry & Lit event today! #TheNoshery @amesbury @SinCNE @wickedcoz… 23 hours ago
- Deadlines coming up for submissions to the two next @levelbestbooks anthologies. mailchi.mp/4edef55d996d/l… 1 day ago
- RT @ConnieHambley: @SinCNE @MeredithLibrary @jessiecrockett @SINCnational Terrific event with many book loving friends! Thank you @Meredith… 2 days ago
- RT @DalePhillips2: @WickedCozys @SinCNE Writeup of the Wicked Cozy Authors in Nashua last night! daletphillips.blogspot.com/2017/04/wicked… 2 days ago
- RT @Clea_Simon: Are you an unpublished mystery writer of color? Sisters in Crime is offering grants (brothers welcomed too)! #amwriting #di… 3 days ago
- RT @MeredithLibrary: Don't miss our @SINCnational anniversary party tomorrow at 1:15pm! bit.ly/2oQmqG7 https://t.co/uPa8AJT9aH 3 days ago
- RT @randomhouse: Congrats @tessgerritsen for winning the 2017 CrimeMaster Award! Her books have sold more than 30 million copies: https://t… 3 days ago
CategoriesAwards Barbara Ross Beth Kanell Blog Summary Book promotion Carlotta Carlyle Conferences Craft Crime Bake Dogs Edith Maxwell Editing Em Moore Event Recap G.M. Malliet Genre Guppies Hallie Ephron Hank Phillippi Ryan Interview J.P. Choquette Judy Copek Kate Flora Lea Wait Libraries Linda Barnes Lisa Haselton Marketing Maureen Milliken Member News Members Michele Dorsey Mo Walsh Nancy Gardner Not Quite Twenty Questions Of Interest Opinion Pat Remick Pauline Alldred Ray Anderson Readers Rosemary Harris SinCNE Social Media Speakers' Bureau Uncategorized Upcoming Events Writers Writing Writing challenges and contests Writing lessons Writing resources Young Adult